I Know Where I'm Going!, 1945, written and directed by Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger.
After having such mixed feelings about the gap between the formal and technical brilliance of Black Narcissus and its toxic cultural context,1 it was a relief to see Powell and Pressburger on less cringeworthy ground. Thematically, a lot of I Know Where I'm Going! is familiar: a Western worldview runs smack into something older and more primitive and basically falls apart. This time the part of the Raj is played by the Hebrides, so there's a lot less cultural and political baggage. Unless, of course, you're a member of the Scottish National Party, in which case it's Black Narcissus all over again.
Like Black Narcissus, this one's a genre-jumper. By the end of the film, it's a romance—after a brief stint in Jack London man v. nature territory—but the opening is straight from American screwball comedy. We're introduced to Joan Webster during the opening credits as a baby, while a stentorian voiceover tells us:
When Joan was only one year old, she already knew where she was going. Going right? Left? No. Straight on.
Later scenes during the credits characterize her as a snob and a striver: she insists that Santa bring her real silk stockings, and she has no time to waste on her schoolmates. When we first see her as an adult, the camera reduces her to a pair of legs plowing straight through a crowd:
The last time I saw a movie use its opening sequence to portray its protagonist as a relentless freight train of ambition and desire, Daniel Day-Lewis was digging for oil. Of course, screwball comedies have always relied on characters who are completely unstoppable: think of Cary Grant in His Girl Friday, or Katherine Hepburn in Bringing Up Baby. It takes an incredible amount of charm to pull off a character like that without souring the tone of the film (which is why Grant and Hepburn usually got those roles). Powell and Pressburger apparently wanted to cast Deborah Kerr, but had to turn to their second choice, Wendy Hiller. It was a fortunate accident, because Hiller has the same combination of overconfidence and blithe indifference to the world around her that characterizes Hepburn's best comedic roles.
Hiller needs all the charm she can muster, because her character is pretty dreadful, at least at the start. And here's where we move away from the classic romantic comedy template: the "unstoppable force" characters are usually on the side of the angels: they're the ones that are absolutely sure that love will conquer all. It's the other character who's allowed to have all the wrong goals. Usually those goals are understandable and innocuous, no matter how misguided: authenticity, Ralph Bellamy, an intercostal clavicle, or Ralph Bellamy. Joan Webster is considerably less likeable.
In Hiller's opening scene, she's telling her father, a middle-class bank manager, that she's leaving town that very evening to be married. When he asks who the groom is, she shows him her works pass for Consolidated Chemical Industries:
You can't marry Consolidated Chemical Industries, but you can do the next best thing and marry its chairman, Sir Robert Bellinger. They're to be married in the Hebrides, as she puts it "away from... people." When her father protests that Bellinger is as old as he is, she replies, "And what's wrong with you, darling?" Like I said, pretty dreadful.
Her motives are perfectly clear and perfectly deplorable: Bellinger's her ticket into the cocooned life of the filthy rich, where timetables are planned out in advance, everything is arranged, and absolutely nothing ever has to be done for oneself. She crosses the threshold at the train station, when one of Bellinger's factotums hands her a neatly typed itinerary.
Powell and Pressburger make Joan's shallow venality abundantly clear in a dream sequence while she's on the train. After fantasizing about being literally married to Consolidated Chemical Industries, she envisions her life to come: inside a bubble made from the plastic that encases her wedding gown, surrounded by lots and lots of money.
So how do Powell and Pressburger get away with having such a horrible person as a heroine? It's not just Wendy Hiller's performance (although that's a lot of it). The tone of the first act is much more comic than the rest of it; we're continually reminded that we're in a comedy. They go so far as to have a Playtime-style visual pun, tracking in tightly on one of Bellinger's agent's stovepipe hat:
And then dissolving from the hat:
To the smokestack of the train as it prepares to leave the station.
I think the jokes are more overt here because as long as it's a comedy, we know Joan is being set up for a fall. Once fog and choppy water prevent her from reaching the island where she is to be married, I Know Where I'm Going! slows way down. There's no place in a film like Bringing Up Baby for a long mournful shot of the landscape, but Powell and Pressburger (courtesy of Erwin Hillier's cinematography) give us just that:
If the first act had moments of languor like the second act does, I don't think there's anything Wendy Hiller could have done to keep audiences from hoping she'd drown.
The change in pace gives Joan time to fall in love with the Scottish countryside, and especially with Torquil MacNeil, a Naval officer and down-on-his-luck Laird whose ancestral home is the island Joan's fiancé is renting. Roger Livesey wisely underplayed the role: he's the straight man to Joan's manic energy.
That's not to say that tone of the film changes entirely; there are a few characters straight out of drawing room comedy. The best of these is Colonel Barnstaple, an eccentric falconer, eagle trainer, ex-military man, and cook. He's played by Captain Charles William Robert Knight, M.C., F.R.P.S., F.Z.S., and it doesn't seem to be much of a stretch for him.
And although they're not onscreen much, special notice must be given to the Robinson family, upper-class British twits who provide Joan with a chilling glimpse of her future with Bellinger.
That's Catherine Lacey, Valentine Dyall (also in Brief Encounter, as Alec's sallow, insinuating friend), and Petula Clark. Yes, that Petula Clark. Her performance suggests she could have had a great career in Children of the Corn-type-roles, if things had gone differently.
Powell and Pressburger background the comedy in this section of the film to give Joan and Torquill breathing room (they could have done a great deal more with the Robinson family, for instance), and the film transitions into a straight romance. Powell apparently loved Scotland, and this section of the film pays careful attention to the local scenery and customs. The highlight is a sequence at a céilidh to celebrate a diamond wedding anniversary.
Joan being Joan, she doesn't react well at all when she realizes she's headed off course (and falling in love with Torquil). Desperate to wrap herself back up in Bellinger's money, she bribes a local boy to take her across to the island despite the weather. And this at the height of Scotland's whirlpool season!
Torquil is dense enough not to know why she's leaving. Fortunately, as is customary in movies of this type, he has a worldly-wise friend who sees what's happening, played with witchlike intensity by Pamela Brown.
Torquil rushes down to the boat and insists on going along, and once again we're in a different sort of movie. The boat sequence could be in a Jack London story, except for the mythical whirlpool (it's called Corryvrecken, and Powell and Pressburger set it up better than I did). It's tense, tight bravura filmmaking, and nothing in the film's screwball-like opening would lead you to believe this is where things were heading.
But despite all the genre-hopping, the whole thing hangs together. The film's finale is the perfect embodiment of Robert McKee's2 advice about endings: Powell and Pressburger give the audience exactly what they want, but in an way they don't expect. In a movie with a mad British falconer, a giant whirlpool, and Petula Clark, you're probably wondering what could possibly be unexpected. Well, I'm. not going to tell you.
- Captain C.W.R. Knight was a dedicated naturalist, and trained Mr. Ramshaw, the eagle in the film. Their partnership went back to the 1920s, when Knight gave a traveling slideshow, film, and lecture presentation. I would have loved to have seen it. Mordaunt Hall reviewed it for the New York Times in the same article as his review of Clara Bow's first sound film (The Wild Party). Knight got top billing.
- Here's how an engine usually gets fixed in a movie. It breaks down for obscure reasons, someone pokes around under the hood for a while (though our view of the engine is blocked by the hood), they say, "That oughta do'er," and slam the hood closed authoritatively, and the engine roars to life. In I Know Where I'm Going!, we see the engine flood, then see Torquil dismantle it, burn the spark plugs dry with gas:
- And reconnect everything, on camera:
- You could make this sequence without those details, but it works here the same way it does in Rififi, ratcheting up the tension by dwelling on every step Torquil has to complete to save their lives.
- This was one of the first British films to use extensive location shooting. Powell was in love with the Hebrides, and it shows. The DVD includes some of his home movies, narrated by Powell's wife (and Scorcese's editor) Thelma Schoonmaker.
- The IMDB (and the Criterion site) has Joan's fiancé's name as "Bellinger," but on the itinerary it's clearly "Bellenger." I've sent the DVD back; does anyone know how it's spelled in the credits?
- For all the location shooting in this film, Roger Livesey never left London: they used a body double for the location shooting and combined rear projection and sets for the closeups. So this shot:
- uses a body double and the actual castle, but the medium shot has Livesey on a set (notice the tree that suddenly appears to Livesey's right).
- As obvious as that is when comparing one frame to the next, while the movie is playing, it's seamless—I wouldn't have noticed at all if it hadn't been pointed out.
- Finlay Currie has a great, if brief, turn as the owner of the boat that's to take Joan across. What Danny Trejo is to inmates and drug traffickers, Currie is to sailors and pirates.
- He was equally well-cast that same year as Abel Magwitch in Great Expectations.
- And speaking of severe looking Scotsmen, during the céilidh scene, I had one of those "Hey, it's that guy!" moments when the son of the old couple celebrating their anniversary was on screen. He's a cheerful looking guy:
- And that's why I couldn't remember where I'd seen him, because the last time I'd seen that face, it was considerably less pleasant. That's John Laurie, who played the horrible crofter in The 39 Steps. Fortunately, the DVD also features an excerpt from The Edge of the World, Michael Powell's first film about the Hebrides, in which Laurie plays a bit closer to type:
- That's the John Laurie I remember!
1If only they'd given up on recreating the subcontinent at Pinewood and set Black Narcissus in Oz. Or outer space.
2I know, I know. But he's right about this.
I adore IKWIG; it feels something like a jeu d'esprit between weightier films for the Archers but it's fizzing with warmth and invention (I love the reveals of the opening credits). Looking at his work in this, Blimp and A Matter of Life and Death it's a mystery to me that Roger Livesey never had a bigger career. I never really paid any attention before now to what he does to the engine, so thank you for pointing it out!
John Laurie has another nice sympathetic turn in The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp (I am looking forward very much to when you get around to it); the surprise of his performances in all of the films is enhanced further for British audiences, to the vast majority of whom he is most familiar from his long running role in the wildly popular sitcom Dad's Army as a comically dour undertaker. It's a testament to his performances that anyone is able to take them seriously.
As far as the engine repairs go, I'm not even sure that his method would work, but there's certainly a lot more detail in the repairs than you might ordinarily see.
That's fascinating about Laurie—I had no idea he was a TV star. From what I've seen of him on film, I think he was aptly cast as a dour undertaker.
John, it is spelled "Bellinger", with an "i", in the on-screen credits.
Thanks for the info—I've updated it in the essay.
My pleasure John. Any excuse to take IKWIG out of the box. If memory serves this was the first Powell & Pressburger I saw, the beginning of a lot of rewarding watching of great movies. It also helped me decide to include Mull on my itinerary when I visited Scotland some years back. Moy Castle is still there, though regrettably the door is locked now.
I'd also like to say how much I enjoy this blog of yours, and how pleasant it is to surf over here and find you've posted again. Now I'm off to look at your review of Carnival of Souls, which just popped out of my Netflix queue.
Thank you, and I'm glad to hear you enjoy the blog. You seem to be under the impression that my name is "John," though—it's Matthew.
Carnival of Souls has one of the all-time great filming locations.
Matthew, I have no idea where that is coming from! My regrets.
Great blog, which I will be spending some time with, as there was a point in my life where I imagined I could actually afford to collect every Criterion. Have come closer than seems reasonable at this point. It was a simple tribute to my early days love of catching the Janus film catalog in various venues in the Bay area. Great memories which many of the Criterion DVDs are instant time portals back to.
As you undoubtedly know, you got a nod from Ebert (which having read several of your entries, is deserved) so expect an influx of comments, and perhaps some older threads to suddenly become active.
This is truly a wonderful concept for a blog and I look forward to catching up.
Glad to hear you enjoy the blog! I'm psyched about the Ebert thing; looking forward to conversing about film with some new people wandering over from there.
Just watched again last night, stunning film. Presumably the back story with the engine strip is that the carburettor was swamped and ingested sea water. Therefore it was stripped, drained and dried (there is an inference of time passing.)Burning the plugs would dry them and help ignite the fuel as the engine is "cold starting".
I've been compiling posts about my favorite interesting women in film, and Pamela Brown ranks high. I really wanted a photo of her tossing dead rabbits about (with those great shaggy dogs!) but this one you've posted is the best I can find. I linked to your good review here: Thanks!
I've just discovered this blog and I have really enjoyed this review of an all-time favourite film of mine.
I was always struck by Pamela Brown's performance in this film and for a long time I assumed she also played the crazy nun in Black Narcissus. It turns out that Pamela was in Cleopatra, though - as the soothsayer.
She was a great actress. As was Wendy - I loved her in Pygmalian.
Over from the Ebert blog - One of my favorite movies - I watch it at the holiday season every year. I'm always struck by the shadows in the film - just one example is on the ceiling in the room Joan occupies for the night before the coming storm. And the title song - irony at its best - "the de'l knows who I'll marry."
I just discovered this blog, and it's brilliant. i also just saw IKWIG for the first time about two weeks ago. . . and as delightful as it is, I supposed from your mordant "Black Narcissus" review that you'd have more trouble with it. I mean the fact that Wendy Hiller's choice between real and authentic values and crass materialistic ones comes down to a choice between a laird who owns his own island and a manufacturer who owns his own chemical company. Hardly "Lady Chatterly's Lover," and a terrific example of the least engaging kind of English snobbery--we despise folks "in trade," you know.
I'm sure you get this all the time but I just discovered this blog and it's brilliant. I love the concept and I love this movie. Your screencaps are lovely.
I've added you to my blogroll, etc. Cheers!
Post a Comment